My Generated Bitcoin Address Overlapped With Someone Else’s

·

In the world of blockchain, one of the most fundamental and fascinating concepts is how cryptographic principles secure digital assets like Bitcoin. A classic illustration from the book Mastering Bitcoin outlines the relationship between private keys, public keys, and Bitcoin addresses: a private key generates a public key, which in turn generates a Bitcoin address — and this process is irreversible.

At its core, your entire Bitcoin wealth rests on a single 256-bit binary number — your private key. Imagine flipping a coin 256 times, recording heads as 0 and tails as 1. The resulting string, when converted to hexadecimal, becomes your private key — the sole artifact that grants control over your funds.

Let’s explore what happens when we generate an address from such a key — and why, surprisingly, it might already exist on the blockchain.

From Private Key to Public Key

Consider this hexadecimal value:

3243F6A8885A308D313198A2E03707344A4093822299F31D0082EFA98EC4E6C8

This is a 256-bit number (64 hex characters, or 32 bytes), perfectly valid in length for a Bitcoin private key. To derive the corresponding public key, we use a command-line tool called Bitcoin Explorer (bx). It runs across Linux, Mac, and Windows, and simplifies cryptographic operations.

Using the bx ec-to-public command:

bx ec-to-public -u 3243F6A8885A308D313198A2E03707344A4093822299F31D0082EFA98EC4E6C8

We get a 65-byte output:

04
2e88d239fb78cee0c1c55943a96dcc8b70adf47e18b53f9ba110b6fb871e1f8b
b119f9161df032167181d623a401dde4091c3e0be2001e4dea3e1f53f851aa3a

The prefix 04 indicates an uncompressed public key, followed by two 32-byte segments: the X and Y coordinates of a point on the elliptic curve secp256k1 — Bitcoin’s cryptographic backbone.

Elliptic curve cryptography (ECC) ensures that deriving the private key from this public point is computationally infeasible. This one-way function is what makes Bitcoin secure.

👉 Discover how cryptographic security protects your digital assets today.

Generating the Bitcoin Address

Now that we have the public key, we proceed to generate the Bitcoin address through a series of standardized transformations:

  1. SHA-256 Hashing: Applies a secure hash algorithm to the public key.
  2. RIPEMD-160 Hashing: Further compresses the result into a 160-bit (20-byte) fingerprint.
  3. Base58Check Encoding: Adds version bytes and checksums to prevent input errors and enhance readability.

The full pipeline using Bitcoin Explorer:

bx ec-to-public -u [private_key] | bx sha256 | bx ripemd160 | bx address-encode

For our example, this yields the address:

17mKugcBDEJbu391Fq41AdwLeGHwJLPRDf

This is a P2PKH (Pay-to-PubKey-Hash) address — the most common format in early Bitcoin transactions.

You can verify any step with bx commands:

Wait — This Address Already Exists?

Curious? Let's check the balance and transaction history of 17mKugcBDEJbu391Fq41AdwLeGHwJLPRDf on a blockchain explorer.

A quick lookup reveals: this address has had four transactions, with the latest dating back to late 2014.

How is that possible?

I didn’t send funds to it. I just generated a random-looking key. Yet someone else appears to have used the exact same Bitcoin address.

The answer lies not in coincidence — but in predictability.

Why Address Collision Is (Almost) Impossible — But Still Happened

The total number of possible private keys is staggeringly large: $ 2^{256} $, or roughly:

115,792,089,237,316,195,423,570,985,008,687,907,853,269,984,665,640,564,039,457,584,007,913,129,639,936

That’s more than the number of atoms in the observable universe — many times over.

So the odds of two people independently generating the same private key are effectively zero.

But here’s the catch: my "random" number wasn’t random at all.

It was derived from the hexadecimal representation of π (pi) starting after the decimal point:

π = 3.243F6A88... (in hex)

By taking those digits and using them as a private key, I introduced predictability — and thus vulnerability.

Anyone who thinks to use π, e, or other well-known constants as private keys will arrive at the same address. And yes — others have thought of it before.

👉 Learn how truly random keys protect you from predictable attacks.

The Critical Rule: Use True Randomness

Bitcoin’s security model assumes that private keys are generated using cryptographically secure random number generators (CSPRNGs).

Wallets like Bitcoin Core, Ledger, or Trezor use high-quality entropy sources — combining system noise, user input timing, and hardware-level randomness — to ensure uniqueness.

If you generate a key using:

Then your funds are at extreme risk.

Best Practice: Always rely on trusted wallet software to generate your keys. Never create them manually or from predictable sources.

Importing a Private Key Into a Wallet

While you shouldn’t use predictable keys, there are legitimate cases for importing custom private keys — such as recovering funds from paper wallets.

To import our example key into Bitcoin Core:

Step 1: Convert to WIF (Wallet Import Format)

Use the command:

bx ec-to-wif -u 3243F6A8885A308D313198A2E03707344A4093822299F31D0082EFA98EC4E6C8

Output:

5JCRYcJrKGLTK6R3PbHopfY9BRdmtrq5TCTesx7x9mQUDeYDfZj

This is the WIF format — a compact, Base58-encoded representation that includes metadata and checksums.

Step 2: Import into Bitcoin Core

Run in the console:

importprivkey 5JCRYcJrKGLTK6R3PbHopfY9BRdmtrq5TCTesx7x9mQUDeYDfZj

Your wallet will begin scanning the blockchain for transactions related to this key.

⚠️ Warning: Only import keys into wallets you fully control. Never expose WIF keys online.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can two people really generate the same Bitcoin address?

A: Theoretically possible — but practically impossible due to the vast size of $ 2^{256} $. If it happens with "random" keys, one or both were likely not truly random.

Q: Is using pi or other constants as a private key dangerous?

A: Extremely. These values are publicly known and easily testable. Anyone can sweep funds sent to addresses derived from them.

Q: How do wallets ensure randomness?

A: They use cryptographically secure random number generators fed by system entropy (mouse movements, timestamps, hardware noise). This ensures near-perfect unpredictability.

Q: What is WIF format used for?

A: Wallet Import Format simplifies backup and transfer of private keys. It includes error-checking to prevent typos during manual entry.

Q: Could someone brute-force my private key?

A: No — not with current or foreseeable technology. Even with all the world’s computing power running for centuries, finding a specific key is statistically negligible.

Q: Are all Bitcoin addresses derived from public keys?

A: Most are (like P2PKH and P2WPKH), but newer types like P2SH or Bech32 may involve scripts or hashes without direct public key exposure initially.

Final Thoughts

The story of generating an address from π teaches a powerful lesson: security depends on unpredictability.

While the math behind elliptic curves and hashing may seem abstract, their real-world implication is simple — your private key must be unique, secret, and random.

Modern wallets handle this automatically. Trust them — not coincidences or clever shortcuts.

👉 Secure your crypto journey with tools built on true randomness and strong encryption.

By understanding how addresses are formed — and how easily flawed assumptions can compromise security — you take a vital step toward becoming a knowledgeable and safe participant in the decentralized economy.